
Archaius, Vol. 3, No. 1, 2026
Submitted 03.08.2026
Published 10.10.2026
Resolving Species Boundaries in Eastern Arc Pygmy Chameleons: A New Rhampholeon (Reptilia: Chamaeleonidae) from Nguru
Petr Nečas & Joseph Mboya
Corresponding author: petr.necas@me.com
Abstract
The Nguru Mountains of Tanzania host a highly localized assemblage of pygmy chameleons of the Rhampholeon uluguruensis/moyeri complex. Recent fieldwork revealed a distinct population of Rhampholeon that differs markedly from all described taxa. Eight males of identical morphology were documented across multiple nocturnal surveys between 1 200–1 660 m a.s.l., in degraded montane forest with dense undergrowth and high leaf litter. The taxon exhibits an exceptionally developed dorsal and lateral cranial crest, an elongated rostral worm‑like appendage directed upwards, and strongly pronounced spiny scalation on the extremities. Conspecificity with R. acuminatus, R. waynelotteri, and R. princeeai is excluded. In accordance with biogeographic isolation and terrae typicae, populations from Nguru are treated as Rhampholeon princeeai, whereas populations from Kanga are treated as Rhampholeon waynelotteri. The name Rhampholeon rubeho is emended to Rhampholeon rubehoensis and Rhampholeon nicolai to Rhampholeon nicolae due to linguistic inconsistencies.
Key words: Rhampholeon, pygmy chameleons, taxonomy, Nguru Mountains, Eastern Arc Mountains, montane forest, microendemism, morphology, species delimitation, cryptic diversity
Introduction
Development of Taxonomy of the African Pygmy Chameleons of the Genus Rhampholeon
The taxonomy of African leaf chameleons, genus Rhampholeon, has undergone significant development over the years, driven by advances in morphological and molecular studies. This genus, which comprises small, cryptic chameleons primarily found in East Africa, has been the subject of extensive research due to its unique evolutionary history and ecological significance.

Rhampholeon spectrum was the first species described, recognized for its distinctive leaf-like appearance and small size (Buchholz, 1874). The initial classification of Rhampholeon species was based primarily on external morphological characteristics. Throughout the 20th century, the number of known species increased to 10. These studies laid the groundwork for recognizing the genus's complexity and the need for more refined taxonomic methods (Necas & Schmidt 2004; Tilbury 2018). The advent of molecular phylogenetics in the late 20th and early 21st centuries revolutionized the taxonomy of Rhampholeon. Matthee & al. (2004) conducted a comprehensive phylogenetic review of the genus, Mariaux & al. (2006): described 3 species from the Eastern Arc Range, Fisseha & al. (2013) reviewed the ''Rhampholeon uluguruensis complex", Branch & al. (2014) described 4 new species from cloud forests of Mozambique, Hughes & al. (2018) deciphered the cryptic diversity in Rhampholeon boulengeri and described 5 new cryptic species from central and west equatorial Africa and finally Menegon & al. (2022) unleashed the cryptic diversity in pygmy chameleons of the Eastern Arc Mountains of Tanzania and described 6 more species.
The genus Rhampholeon has a scattered distribution over all equatorial Africa, with most species inhabiting small, isolated montane refugia. Despite some species developed very bizarre appearance with various spikes and cranial and nasal protrusions, most species are morphologically rather primitive. Many species can not be recognized unequivocally based on morphological features and only location and molecular analysis can confirm their belonging to a certain species. The rapid increase in desciptions of new species and splitting of previously widespread species resulted into tripling the number of known species in the first quarter of 21st century to today's 30 known species.
Research has shown that vicariance and climate change played crucial roles in the speciation of Rhampholeon species. The fragmentation of forests due to climatic shifts and geological events, such as the rifting in East Africa, led to the isolation of populations and subsequent speciation. This process is evident in the distinct geographic distributions of Rhampholeon species, with many being confined to isolated montane forests (Menegon & al. 2022). The refined taxonomy of Rhampholeon has significant implications for conservation. Accurate species identification is essential for assessing the conservation status of these chameleons and implementing effective protection measures. Many Rhampholeon species are threatened by habitat loss and fragmentation, making it crucial to prioritise their conservation based on robust taxonomic knowledge (Hughes & al. 2018).
Geology and Geomorphology
The Nguru Mountains and the adjacent Kanga Forest Reserve form part of the Eastern Arc Mountains, a chain of ancient Precambrian crystalline massifs in eastern Tanzania. Their geological substrate consists primarily of metamorphic gneisses, granulites, and schists belonging to the Mozambique Belt, a formation that has remained tectonically stable for tens of millions of years. This geological antiquity has produced steeply dissected slopes, narrow ridges, deeply incised valleys, and isolated summit plateaus separated by sharp elevational gradients. The Nguru massif reaches approximately 2 400 m at its highest ridges. Kanga Forest Reserve forms a smaller, isolated block rising from roughly 300 m to a maximum elevation of 1 360 m. The two systems are separated by an approximately 8‑km‑wide corridor of fully deforested lowland, eliminating ecological connectivity and isolating forest‑dependent taxa.
Climate
The Nguru–Kanga system lies within the humid Eastern Arc climatic zone, characterised by high annual rainfall and strong orographic effects. Moist air masses from the Indian Ocean rise along the eastern escarpments, producing persistent cloud cover and heavy precipitation on windward slopes. Rainfall is bimodal, with long rains typically from March to May and short rains from October to December. Upper montane zones experience frequent mist, reduced solar radiation, and stable temperatures with minimal seasonal variation. In contrast, the lower slopes and intervening lowlands are markedly drier, creating sharp ecological gradients that reinforce isolation between forest blocks.

Vegetation
Vegetation in the Nguru–Kanga system reflects these climatic and elevational contrasts. The Nguru Mountains support extensive tracts of submontane, montane, and upper montane forest, including cloud‑forest formations dominated by Ocotea, Podocarpus, Syzygium, and diverse understory assemblages of Impatiens, Saintpaulia, Begonia, and Cola. The upper ridges harbour moss‑laden, epiphyte‑rich forests with high levels of plant endemism. Kanga Forest Reserve, though smaller and lower in elevation, contains remnants of submontane forest with characteristic Eastern Arc taxa such as Newtonia, Macaranga, and Sorindeia, interspersed with dense thickets and riverine forest along perennial streams. The sharp transition to surrounding dry lowland vegetation further accentuates the ecological isolation of both blocks.
Endemicity and Biogeography
The Nguru–Kanga system exhibits the extreme microendemism characteristic of the Eastern Arc Mountains, one of the world's major centres of ancient biodiversity (Burgess et al. 2007; Rovero et al. 2014). Geological stability, climatic buffering, and long‑term forest persistence have allowed isolated lineages to diverge independently on individual mountain blocks. Endemicity in Nguru is documented across multiple clades. Examples include forest birds such as Sheppardia gunningi nguruensis (Fjeldså et al. 2010), amphibians such as Arthroleptis nguruensis and microendemic Nectophrynoides species (Menegon et al. 2004; Loader et al. 2011), and numerous plants including endemic Saintpaulia, Impatiens, and Cola taxa (Luke 2005; Janssens et al. 2009). Small mammals such as forest‑restricted populations of Beamys hindei also show distributions tied to intact forest patches (Stanley et al. 1998). These patterns mirror the biogeographic processes shaping the chameleon fauna.
Chameleon Fauna
The chameleon fauna of the Nguru Mountains and the adjacent Kanga Forest Reserve consists of several species. Among them, Kinyongia fischeri is strictly endemic to this massif and does not occur outside the Nguru block. Additional microendemics include Rhampholeon waynelotteri and Rhampholeon princeeai, both restricted to isolated forest patches within the Nguru–Kanga system. The remaining species are considered widely distributed across the Eastern Arc and adjacent regions.
Taxonomic list:
Chamaeleo dilepis Leach, 1819
Kinyongia fischeri (Reichenow, 1887)
Kinyongia oxyrhina (Böhme, 1989)
Rhampholeon acuminatus Günther, 1892
Rhampholeon waynelotteri Menegon, Lyakurwa, Loader & Tolley, 2022
Rhampholeon princeeai Menegon, Lyakurwa, Loader & Tolley, 2022
Rieppeleon brevicaudatus (Matschie, 1892)
Trioceros deremensis (Matschie, 1892)
Trioceros melleri (Gray, 1865)
Trioceros werneri (Tornier, 1899)

The detailed analysis of the morphology conducted by the first author, together with the repeating biogeographic patterns characteristic of the Eastern Arc Mountains, makes it highly probable that the local population currently assigned to Kinyongia oxyrhina represents a cryptic, undescribed species distinct from the populations of the Uluguru and Udzungwa Mountains (Nečas pers. obs.). The same pattern emerges in Trioceros deremensis, where the E Usambara, Nguru and Uluguru lineages show divergence consistent with long‑term isolation within this massif (Nečas pers. obs.). Tilbury (2010) and Tilbury & Tolley (2009) note that Trioceros werneri shows clear geographic structuring across the Eastern Arc Mountains, with distinct lineages in the Uluguru, Nguru, Ukaguru, Rubeho, and Udzungwa massifs. Although the species is morphologically conservative, these populations differ in several external traits, including general body proportions, colour patterns, and the form, colour, length, and number of the rostral horns. The degree of horn development in females also varies between mountain blocks. These differences indicate that T. werneri represents a complex of independently evolving lineages, and the Nguru–Kanga population fits this structure as a likely separate lineage within the broader complex. Taken together, the morphological observations, the biogeographic isolation of each massif, and the documented diversity patterns in K. oxyrhina, T. deremensis, and T. werneri strongly suggest that the Nguru–Kanga system harbours multiple unrecognised chameleon taxa whose distinct evolutionary histories have been obscured by the morphological conservatism typical of Eastern Arc forest chameleons and insufficient research.
Pygmy Chameleons of the Nguru–Kanga System
The Nguru Mountains and the adjacent Kanga Forest Reserve host pygmy chameleons belonging to two genera, Rhampholeon and Rieppeleon. The Rhampholeon uluguruensis/moyeri subgroup is represented by three described taxa—Rhampholeon acuminatus, Rhampholeon princeeai, and Rhampholeon waynelotteri—all confined to narrow montane forest fragments. In contrast, Rieppeleon brevicaudatus is a widespread species occurring across multiple Eastern Arc blocks and represents the only broadly distributed pygmy chameleon in the region.
Rhampholeon acuminatus
Terra typica: Tanzania, Morogoro Region, Nguru Mountains, Nguru South Catchment Forest Reserve, Komkore Forest above Ubili village (6°2'29" S; 37°30'40.5" E), elevation 1500–1600 m.
Range: Restricted to Mkingu Nature Reserve in the Nguru Mountains.
Rhampholeon waynelotteri
Terra typica: Kanga Forest Reserve in the Nguru Mountains landscape, at 1280 m a.s.l. (–5.9168; 37.7056), Mvomero District, Morogoro Region, Tanzania.
Range: Known only from Kanga and Nguru Mountains. The Nguru population—separated from Kanga by an ~8 km lowland corridor—was not included in the phylogenetic analysis; based on geographic proximity and morphological similarity, it is tentatively assigned to this species.
Rhampholeon princeeai
Terra typica: Mkingu Nature Reserve in the Nguru Mountains, at 1870 m a.s.l. (–6.0655; 37.4907), Mvomero District, Morogoro Region, Tanzania.
Range: Known only from its type locality, likely confined to montane forest above 1800 m. Within Mkingu, R. princeeai is syntopic with R. acuminatus and occurs sympatrically with the Nguru population of R. waynelotteri.
Rieppeleon brevicaudatus
Terra typica: Derema, East Usambara Mountains, Tanzania.
Range: Widespread across eastern Tanzania, occurring from the East and West Usambara Mountains southwards through the Nguru, Uluguru, Udzungwa, Magombera, and Mahenge blocks. In the Nguru Mountains it is confined to lower elevations and persists in both primary and secondary habitats.

Species Delimitation and Practical Taxonomic Treatment
The molecular evidence presented by Menegon et al. (2022) reveals several divergent mitochondrial lineages within the Rhampholeon uluguruensis/moyeri complex, yet the taxonomic decisions derived from these data are not adequately justified. The authors acknowledge the extreme morphological conservatism of the group, but nevertheless describe new species in cases where phenotypic, ecological, and biogeographic evidence is minimal or absent. The most problematic example is the proposed separation of Rhampholeon princeeai and Rhampholeon waynelotteri, two lineages reported from the same mountain block without any diagnosable morphological differences, ecological separation, or niche partitioning. Their recognition as distinct species rests solely on mitochondrial divergence, a criterion insufficient for species delimitation in a radiation known for deep haplotype structure and negligible morphometric disparity.
This situation is biologically inconsistent with the fundamental mechanisms of species recognition in chameleons. Rand (1961) demonstrated that forest chameleons rely almost entirely on visual signals—cranial ornamentation, silhouette, and deployable display structures—for species and sex identification. Nečas (1999) and Tolley & Herrel (2013) further emphasised that chameleons possess no alternative recognition systems: they lack acoustic communication, pheromonal species cues, and behavioural repertoires capable of compensating for identical morphology. In sympatric assemblages, these visual traits undergo character displacement, ensuring that coexisting species differ clearly in head morphology to prevent misdirected courtship and hybridisation. Across Chamaeleonidae, sympatric species consistently maintain distinct visual identities; identical cranial profiles in syntopy do not occur.
Although cryptic species exist in the family, such as the genetically divergent but morphologically indistinguishable lineages of Rhampholeon boulengeri documented by Hughes et al. (2018), these lineages are strictly allopatric. The same applies to the diversification of the former Rhampholeon spectrum complex, where Tapondjou Nkonmeneck et al. (2022) demonstrated mitochondrial structuring without morphological differentiation, again only in geographically separated populations. In both cases, the absence of morphological divergence is biologically acceptable precisely because the lineages do not coexist.
The princeeai–waynelotteri pair is therefore unique in the entire family: two purported species said to occur together, yet lacking any difference in ornamentation, silhouette, or ecological niche. With no visual differentiation and no alternative recognition mechanisms, such a pair would have no functional means to maintain reproductive isolation. A syntopic chameleon without a unique visual identity is an evolutionary impossibility. The only remaining distinction—mitochondrial haplotypes—has no role in species recognition and cannot support species boundaries in a visually driven lineage. This makes the current separation biologically implausible and taxonomically unstable. If males are indistinguishable, same is true for females. AT one location (see below), probably females of three taxa are living, not distinguishable by morphometric means.
A strict synonymy of R. princeeai under R. waynelotteri would be defensible on evidentiary grounds, but it is not practical because the two names have different terrae typicae and known ranges, separated by an approximately 8‑km‑wide lowland corridor that prevents gene flow. To preserve nomenclatural stability while acknowledging the lack of diagnostic characters, we propose a pragmatic, operational solution:
All Rhampholeon of this subgroup from the Nguru Mountains should, for now, be treated as Rhampholeon princeeai, and all from Kanga as Rhampholeon waynelotteri, until additional data allow reliable separation based on morphology or ecology.
This approach avoids unstable synonymy, respects type localities, and provides a functional framework for identification while recognising that the current evidence is insufficient to justify the formal species boundaries proposed by Menegon et al. (2022).
Field Observations of a Potentially Undescribed Rhampholeon Taxon
In February 2025, the junior author made an important discovery: a pygmy chameleon belonging to the Rhampholeon uluguruensis/moyeri complex, but clearly differing from all described taxa. Initially, the suspicion was that the specimen represented an unusually developed individual. However, during five subsequent field visits, a total of eight males of identical morphology were documented, all encountered during nocturnal searches.

The average perch height ranged between 50–90 cm above ground, consistently on the leaves of forest‑floor plants. The biotope consists of secondary to degraded primary montane forest with dense undergrowth and abundant leaf litter under the dominant trees Newtonia buchananii, Milicia excelsa and Khaya anotheca.
Locality
The locality lies on the Nguru massif at between 1650 and 1860 m a.s.l., within the Mkingu Forest Reserve. The exact coordinates are withheld for conservation reasons. No female was ever observed in copulation with these males, making conspecificity assessment impossible. Diagnostic features in this complex are generally weakly developed in males and even less obvious in females, preventing reliable association.
The taxon has never been found syntopically with Rhampholeon acuminatus. The only chameleon species observed in syntopy was Kinyongia oxyrhina; no other chameleons were recorded.
Description
It is a rather small Rhampholeon, reaching a maximum total length of 57 mm. Its general appearance corresponds to the typical morphology of the R. uluguruensis/moyeri complex, but several traits are exceptionally well developed, in some cases extremely so.
The dorsal crest is heavily crenulated. The concave segments consist of 13–15 dorsal scales, while the peaks bear prominent, strongly enlarged spikes formed by pointed sub‑conical scales approximately three times higher than surrounding crest scales, giving the crest a serrated, spiky appearance.
The lateral crest rises above the eyes in a high, very prominent spike, connected across the head by a distinct, elevated interorbital ridge. Posterior to the supraorbital peak, the lateral crest carries two additional prominent peaks, each about half the height of the main supraorbital spike, producing a serrated outline.
The rostral flap is long, comprising 10–30% of the orbit diameter. It bears a thick, soft worm‑like appendage above the upper lip, directed as a rule upwards.
The casque apex slightly but clearly exceeds the height of the dorsal crest.
Spiky scales on the extremities are also strongly developed.
Conspecificity with Rhampholeon acuminatus is excluded. The taxon also differs significantly from the descriptions and original illustrations of both Rhampholeon waynelotteri and Rhampholeon princeeai. The conclusion is that it very likely represents a previously unidentified taxon, further enriching the chameleon fauna of the Nguru Mountains.
Nomenclatorical notes
The paper of Menegon et al. (2022) demonstrates a contradictory approach to the routine of naming new species, revealing several constraints worth noting. In zoological taxonomy, the long‑standing convention has been to assign species names that bear a direct and informative relationship to the organism or to the circumstances of its discovery. Classical authors routinely derived epithets from diagnostic morphology, ecological or behavioral traits, biogeographic affinities, or the locality and context of collection. Patronyms were traditionally reserved for individuals directly or indirectly connected to the taxon—collectors, expedition leaders, sponsors, or researchers whose work materially contributed to the discovery. Although the International Code of Zoological Nomenclature permits arbitrary honorific names, it does not alter the historical expectation that nomenclature should serve a documentary function. This expectation is well reflected in the literature: Winston (1999) emphasizes the descriptive role of names in species documentation; Dubois (2000) argues for etymologies that convey meaningful information; Minelli (2019) traces the historical linkage between patronyms and persons involved in collection or study; and Evenhuis (2008) explicitly criticizes gratuitous honorifics that lack relevance to the organism. Together, these works demonstrate that while the Code allows non‑contextual patronyms, the scholarly tradition of zoological systematics has consistently regarded such names as inconsistent with the discipline's documentary and scientific aims.

Menegon et al. (2022) exhibit also a significant inconsistency in the formulation and explanation of species‑group names. Several patronyms lack explicit grammatical definition, others are incorrectly formed, and some are assigned grammatical categories that contradict their actual morphological structure. Although the ICZN does not require authors to explain etymologies, it does require that names be formed according to the rules of Latin grammar (Art. 31.1) and that incorrect Latinization constitutes an incorrect original spelling subject to mandatory correction (Art. 32.5.1).
Rhampholeon colemani
"Rhampholeon colemani is named in honour of Carter Coleman, who for more than 25 years has raised funds and campaigned for the conservation of Tanzania's forests."
The grammatical status is not stated. By form, colemani is a patronym in the masculine singular genitive, consistent with ICZN Art. 31.1.2, which specifies that names formed from personal names should take the genitive ending ‑i for men.
Rhampholeon sabini
"The species name is a patronym for Andy Sabin who provides financial support to many organizations and is actively engaged with community and environmental programs around the world."
Again, the grammatical category is not stated. The epithet sabini is a masculine singular genitive patronym (ICZN Art. 31.1.2), but the omission of this information contributes to inconsistency in the paper's nomenclatural practice.
Rhampholeon nicolai
"This species is named after Nicola Colangelo, an entrepreneur and industrialist who worked in Tanzania for most of his life."
The grammatical status is not stated. The epithet nicolai is intended as a masculine singular genitive patronym. However, this formation is grammatically incorrect. Under ICZN Art. 31.1.2, personal names ending in ‑a that are masculine are treated as Latin first‑declension nouns and form the genitive in ‑ae. Therefore, the correct formation is nicolae, not nicolai. Because this is a mandatory correction of an incorrect original spelling under Art. 32.5.1, the name must be emended to Rhampholeon nicolae (ZooBank LSID for this publication: urn:lsid:zoobank.org:pub:44BF8F3D-A5AB-4841-B2DE-99ED78E5BB4A).
Rhampholeon princeeai
"The species is named after Richard Williams, better known by his stage name Prince Ea, an American activist and inspirational spoken word artist, poet, rapper and filmmaker."
"The specific epithet is considered to be a noun in apposition."
This is linguistically incorrect. The epithet princeeai is morphologically a genitive patronym, not a nominative noun in apposition. ICZN Art. 11.2 requires names to be formed in the Latin alphabet; Art. 31.1.2 requires correct Latin genitive formation for patronyms. A name cannot be "considered" a noun in apposition if its form is genitive. Furthermore, the trivial name "Princeeai's Pygmy Chameleon" used by the authors confirms that the intended meaning is possessive, not appositional. The honoree is "Prince Ea," not "Prince Eai," and therefore the epithet must be treated as a patronym in the masculine singular genitive. The correct vernacular form is "Prince Ea's Pygmy Chameleon."
Rhampholeon rubeho
"The species is named after the mountain block (Rubeho) where the type series was collected and where it is considered to be restricted."
"The specific epithet is considered to be a noun in apposition."
This formation is linguistically and nomenclaturally problematic. ICZN Art. 31.1.3 allows geographic names to be used as nouns in apposition, but only when they are already Latin nouns. Rubeho is not a Latin noun; it is a Swahili toponym. Under Art. 11.3 and Recommendation 11A, vernacular words should be latinized. The correct latinization of a geographic epithet is typically ‑ensis (e.g., rubehoensis) or a genitive (e.g., rubehonis). Using the nominative Rubeho as a noun in apposition violates the requirement that names be formed according to Latin grammar (Art. 31.1). Therefore, the epithet should be corrected to Rhampholeon rubehoensis. (ZooBank LSID for this publication: urn:lsid:zoobank.org:pub:44BF8F3D-A5AB-4841-B2DE-99ED78E5BB4A)
The nomenclatural problem begins with a direct and irreconcilable conflict inside the ICZN. The Code simultaneously maintains two provisions that cannot coexist in Latin. First, the foundational Linnaean principle, affirmed in the Preamble and in Article 11.2, requires that zoological names be Latin in form and grammar. Second, Article 31.1.3 allows modern geographic names to be used as nouns in apposition. These two rules contradict each other because Latin provides no grammatical possibility whatsoever for naming an animal with a nominative noun that denotes a geographic entity. This is not a matter of tradition or preference. It is a structural impossibility in the language.
In zoological Latin, specific names must be formed either as adjectives agreeing with the genus in gender, or as genitives indicating origin, possession, or dedication. These are the only mechanisms by which Latin expresses relationships between a genus and its species. The narrow exception, nouns in apposition, applies only when the epithet is a Latin noun describing a property or metaphorical resemblance of the organism, such as gallus, meaning rooster, used when a chameleon's casque evokes the silhouette of a rooster, or cristifer, literally crest‑bearer, a legitimate morphological descriptor. These constructions are meaningful because they are Latin nouns describing the animal itself.
This logic does not and cannot apply to topographic names. Latin has no grammatical option to name an animal with a nominative noun that denotes a mountain, region, river, locality, or any other geographic entity. Not if the name is vernacular. Not if it is latinized. Not even if it is originally Latin. And absolutely not if it is plural. Combinations such as Rhampholeon newyork or Salamandra alpae are not merely inelegant; they are grammatical impossibilities, linguistic nonsense, and frankly misguided to anyone with even elementary competence in Latin or in Roman and Slavic linguistic traditions, which preserve the semantic logic inherited from Latin. These formations violate the core structure of the language and reduce zoological nomenclature to a heap of barbarisms glued onto Latin endings.
The ICZN's allowance of nomina topographica as nouns in apposition therefore authorizes forms that Latin cannot produce. This is why names such as Calumma tarzan (Gehring et al. 2010), Rhampholeon monteslunae (Hughes et al. 2024), and Rhampholeon rubeho (Menegon et al. 2022) are not merely non‑Latin. They are grammatical impossibilities in Latin, incompatible with the foundational Linnaean principle that zoological names must be Latin in form and grammar.
To preserve linguistic integrity while respecting the Code's rules on availability, we therefore register Rhampholeon rubehoensis as the correct Latinized form, treating this as an formal, nomenclatural act under ZooBank LSID for this publication: urn:lsid:zoobank.org:pub:44BF8F3D-A5AB-4841-B2DE-99ED78E5BB4A. We express the expectation that the ICZN will revise Article 31.1.3 to eliminate these barbarisms and restore the strict Latin grammar and meaningful naming practice intended and explicitely mentioned by Linnaeus and upheld by classical taxonomists. Linaeus (1737), in his Critica Botanica wrote literally: "Nomina generica barbara sunt rejicienda." (Barbarous generic names are to be rejected.)
While it is understandable and practically useful for fieldwork and educational outreach that Menegon et al. (2022) provide trivial (vernacular) names alongside the scientific names governed by the ICZN, their treatment of trivial names again reveals notable inconsistencies. A positive observation is that, although their scientific naming practice fails to follow several scholarly standards, the trivial names are generally more closely related to the species in question, for example: Uluguru Pygmy Chameleon (for Rhampholeon uluguruensis), Moyer's Pygmy Chameleon (for Rhampholeon moyeri), Beraducci's Pygmy Chameleon (for Rhampholeon beraduccii), Nguru Spiny Pygmy Chameleon (for Rhampholeon acuminatus), Uzungwa Scarp's Pygmy Chameleon (for Rhampholeon colemani), Nguu North Pygmy Chameleon (for Rhampholeon sabini).
It is debatable whether scientific and trivial names should differ so substantially, as it is not practical to remember, for example, that "Uzungwa Scarp's Pygmy Chameleon" corresponds to Rhampholeon colemani, whereas "Coleman's Pygmy Chameleon" would be more elegant, intuitive, and practical; but both logics work in fact. Nevertheless, because trivial names are not regulated by any formal code, the practice of Menegon et al. (2022) remains acceptable.
Concerns arise with the choice "Rubeho's Pigmy Chameleon" (for Rhampholeon rubeho), where the possessive form "Rubeho's" may incorrectly imply that Rubeho is a person rather than a mountain range. The appropriate trivial name should therefore be "Rubeho Pygmy Chameleon."
Menegon et al. (2020) repeatedly use the non‑standard spelling Pigmy Chameleon, which is incorrect in modern zoological English. The proper form is Pygmy Chameleon. The word derives from the ancient Greek πυγμαῖος (pygmaios), meaning "dwarf‑sized" or "small of stature," itself rooted in pygmē, "the length of a fist." Because the original Greek uses the letter υ (y), the scientifically accepted English spelling preserves this form. Pigmy is a later phonetic simplification that occasionally appears in older texts, but it is not used in contemporary taxonomy or wildlife nomenclature and should be avoided in formal scientific writing.
In two further cases, the scientific naming practice followed the option of naming a species after a person's first name rather than the family name: "Nicola's Pigmy Chameleon" (for Rhampholeon nicolai emended to R. nicolae), named after Nicola Colangelo (note the same spelling of Pigmy instead of Pygmy as in R. rubehoensis), and "Wayne's Pygmy Chameleon" (for Rhampholeon waynelotteri), named after and dedicated to Wayne Lotter. While the scientific names ensure uniqueness within the genus and cannot be confused, trivial names benefit from clarity and recognizability. It is therefore more meaningful to use the family name rather than the first name: "Colangelo's Pygmy Chameleon" and "Lotter's Pygmy Chameleon," or, if preferred, the full names: "Nicola Colangelo's Pygmy Chameleon" and "Wayne Lotter's Pygmy Chameleon."
Princeeai's Pygmy Chameleon (for Rhampholeon princeeai) has been discussed above already, it should be Changed to Prince Ea's Pygmy Chameleon.
Methodological and Terminological Inconsistencies
The comparison of morphological data with Menegon & al. (2022) is partly a bit problematic and can lead to inconsistencies. It is because their definition of morphological terms is in many cases confusing:
Original citation: "...species were measured using digital callipers to the nearest mm". They state they measured in mm but they give the dimensions in hundredths of millimetres, a precision, which is impossible in measuring the chameleon morphological features, especially soft tissues in fact.
Original citation: "Snout-Vent Length (SVL) – tip of the snout to the anterior edge of the cloaca; Tail Length (TL) – tip of tail to posterior edge of the cloaca." The problem is, there is no "anterior and posterior edge of the cloaca". This definition is used in Batrachology, where the cloacal fissure e.g. in the genus Salamandra is longitudinal and has an anterior and posterior edge; not so in chameleons, where the cloacal fissure is situated transversally and defined as the meeting of the anterior and posterior cloacal lips. From the external morphological view, the only visible cloacal structure usable for measurement is the cloacal fissure, therefore, I assume, that they meant this structure and that actually, the measurements were done using this logic. If not, the sum of SVL and TL would not equal total length and relative tail lengths would be calculated wrongly, which seem not to be the case.
Original citation: "Head Length (HL) - from just behind the top of the casque to the tip of the snout" - as almost all Rhampholeon specimens possess a rostral protuberance, it is not clear, whether they measured it with it or without. Let us assume they meant actually "without rostral flap".
Original citation: "Head Width (HW) – maximum width of head" - as the point, where the head might be the widest can lay before, between or behind the orbits, this parameter is very unpractical if not determined where it should be measured.
Original citation: "Inter-orbital Distance (ID) – minimum width between orbits across crown" - as there is no common use of the term "crown" in chameleons and it has previously been used only by Branch & al. (2014) without any explanation, let us assume, an area demarcated rostrally by inter-orbital crest, dorsally by the top of the casque and laterally res. postero-laterally by the cranial lateral crests is meant.
Original citation: "Parietal Crest to Snout (PCS) – distance from the middle of parietal crest to the tip of the snout from a sagittal view." This is absolutely confusing term, as it is unclear how to define "the middle of parietal crest" and therefore, this measurement is of questionable value, even if the point of bifurcation of the parietal crest is meant in fact.
Conclusions
The Nguru Mountains continue to reveal the deep biological isolation characteristic of the Eastern Arc, where long‑term forest persistence and steep elevational gradients have produced highly localized vertebrate lineages. Within this landscape, the discovery of a morphologically exceptional pygmy chameleon belonging to the Rhampholeon uluguruensis/moyeri complex demonstrates that the chameleon fauna of Nguru remains incompletely documented. The species shows an unusually developed cranial and dorsal ornamentation, expressed consistently across multiple individuals, and differs clearly from R. acuminatus, R. waynelotteri, and R. princeeai. Its discovery is reported here, but the clarification of its taxonomic status and its formal description—should future evidence confirm its validity—remain tasks for subsequent integrative work.
The broader taxonomic context reinforces the need for caution. The Eastern Arc pygmy chameleons exhibit deep mitochondrial structuring but extreme morphological conservatism, a combination that complicates species delimitation when lineages occur in sympatry. The current separation of R. princeeai and R. waynelotteri lacks functional biological justification; their recognition as distinct species is unsupported by diagnosable morphology or ecological partitioning. To maintain nomenclatural stability while acknowledging the limitations of available evidence, populations from Nguru are treated operationally as Rhampholeon princeeai, and those from Kanga as Rhampholeon waynelotteri. Additionally, the epithet Rhampholeon rubeho is corrected to Rhampholeon rubehoensis to conform with Latin grammatical standards.
Taken together, the morphological distinctiveness of the newly documented Nguru species, the biogeographic isolation of the massif, and the recurring pattern of microendemism across the Eastern Arc strongly suggest that the Nguru Mountains harbour additional unrecognised chameleon diversity. Continued fieldwork, combined with integrative taxonomic approaches, will be essential for resolving species boundaries within Rhampholeon and for safeguarding the unique evolutionary heritage of this ancient montane system.
Literature
Branch, W.R., Tolley, K.A., Cunningham, M., Bauer, A.M., Menegon, M. & Broadley, D.G. 2014. Pygmy chameleons of the Rhampholeon spectrum complex in Mozambique, with the description of three new species. African Journal of Herpetology 63: 91–110.
Buchholz, R. 1874. Rhampholeon spectrum. Monatsberichte der Königlich Preussischen Akademie der Wissenschaften zu Berlin 1874: 115–118.
Burgess, N.D., Butynski, T.M., Cordeiro, N.J., Doggart, N.H., Fjeldså, J., Howell, K.M., Kilahama, F.B., Loader, S.P., Lovett, J.C., Mbilinyi, B., Menegon, M., Moyer, D.C., Nashanda, E., Perkin, A., Rovero, F., Stanley, W.T. & Stuart, S.N. 2007. The biological importance of the Eastern Arc Mountains of Tanzania and Kenya. Biological Conservation 134: 209–231.
Fisseha, M., Tolley, K.A. & Matthee, C.A. 2013. Phylogeography of the Rhampholeon uluguruensis complex in Tanzania. African Journal of Herpetology 62: 1–15.
Fjeldså, J., Kiure, J., Doggart, N. & Burgess, N.D. 2010. Distribution of highland forest birds across the Eastern Arc Mountains. Journal of East African Natural History 99: 1–22.
Gehring, P.-S.; Pabijan, M.; Ratsoavina, F. M.; Köhler, J.; Mebert, K. & Glaw, F. 2010. Calumma tarzan. Eine neue Chamäleonart aus Madagaskar braucht dringend Hilfe! Reptilia (Münster) 15(86): 60–64.
Hughes, D. F.; Behangana, M.; Lukwago, W.; Menegon, M.; Dehling, J. M.; Wagner, P.; Kusamba, C.; Greenbaum, E. 2024. Taxonomy of the Rhampholeon boulengeri Complex (Sauria: Chamaeleonidae): Five New Species from Central Africa's Albertine Rift. Zootaxa 5458(4): 451–494.
Hughes, D.F., Tolley, K.A., Behangana, M., Greenbaum, E., Kusamba, C., Zassi‑Boulou, A.G. & Channing, A. 2018. Cryptic diversity in Rhampholeon boulengeri from Central and West Africa. Zoological Journal of the Linnean Society 184: 1–28.
Janssens, S.B., Knox, E.B. & Smets, E.F. 2009. A new species of Impatiens from the Nguru Mountains. Systematic Botany 34: 595–602.
Linnaeus, C. 1737. Critica Botanica. In qua nomina plantarum generica, specifica, & variantia examini subjiciuntur, selectuntur, firmantur. Lugduni Batavorum [Leiden]: Apud Conradi Wishhoff. xxiv + 270 pp.
Loader, S.P., Menegon, M., Salvidio, S. & Wilkinson, M. 2011. Three new species of Nectophrynoides from the Eastern Arc Mountains, Tanzania. African Journal of Herpetology 60: 1–17.
Luke, W.R.Q. 2005. New and little‑known Eastern Arc plant species. Journal of East African Natural History 94: 1–20.
Mariaux, J., Lutzmann, N. & Tilbury, C.R. 2006. The genus Rhampholeon in Tanzania, with the description of three new species. Zootaxa 1238: 1–36.
Matthee, C.A., Tilbury, C.R. & Townsend, T. 2004. A phylogenetic review of the African leaf chameleons: genus Rhampholeon. Proceedings of the Royal Society B 271: 1967–1975.
Menegon, M., Salvidio, S. & Tilbury, C.R. 2004. A new species of Nectophrynoides from the Eastern Arc Mountains, Tanzania. African Journal of Herpetology 53: 1–12.
Menegon, M., Lyakurwa, J.V., Loader, S.P. & Tolley, K.A. 2022. Cryptic diversity in pygmy chameleons of the Eastern Arc Mountains of Tanzania, with description of six new species. Acta Herpetologica 17: 85–113.
Minelli, A. 2019. Names and naming in zoology. History and Philosophy of the Life Sciences 41: 1–20.
Nečas, P. 1999. Chameleons – Nature's Hidden Jewels. Edition Chimaira, 348pp.
Nečas, P. & Schmidt, W. 2004. Rhampholeon spectrum complex: taxonomy and distribution. Salamandra 40: 123–140.
Rand, A.S. 1961. A suggested explanation for sexual dimorphism in chameleons. Breviora 132: 1–11.
Rovero, F., Menegon, M., Fjeldså, J., Collett, L., Doggart, N., Leonard, C., Norton, G. & Platts, P.J. 2014. Targeted vertebrate surveys enhance biodiversity conservation in the Eastern Arc Mountains. Oryx 48: 80–89.
Stanley, W.T., Hutterer, R. & Howell, K.M. 1998. Small mammals of the Eastern Arc Mountains. Journal of East African Natural History 87: 91–100.
Tapondjou Nkonmeneck, B., Tolley, K.A., Burger, M., Greenbaum, E., Kusamba, C. & Channing, A. 2022. Cryptic diversity in the Rhampholeon spectrum complex from Central Africa. African Journal of Herpetology 71: 45–68.
Tilbury, C.R. 2010. Chameleons of Africa: An Atlas of Chameleon Diversity in Africa. Edition Chimaira, 400pp.
Tilbury, C.R. & Tolley, K.A. 2009. The diversity of Trioceros werneri in the Eastern Arc Mountains. African Journal of Herpetology 58: 23–38.
Tolley, K.A. & Herrel, A. 2013. The biology of chameleons. University of California Press, 1–15.
Winston, J.E. 1999. Describing Species: Practical Taxonomic Procedure for Biologists. Columbia University Press, 512pp.
ZooBank LSID for this publication: urn:lsid:zoobank.org:pub:44BF8F3D-A5AB-4841-B2DE-99ED78E5BB4A
Nečas, P. & J. Mboya (2026):
Resolving Species Boundaries in Eastern Arc Pygmy Chameleons: A New Rhampholeon (Reptilia: Chamaeleonidae) from Nguru. Archaius 3(1): 6
Page 6
